Monetary Vs Fiscal Policy Essays

On By In 1

The aims of fiscal and monetary policy are similar. They could both be used to:

  • Maintain positive economic growth (close to long-run trend rate of 2.5%)
  • Aim for full employment
  • Keep inflation low (inflation target of 2%)

The principal aim of fiscal and monetary policy is to reduce cyclical fluctuations in the economic cycle. In recent years, governments have often relied on monetary policy to target low inflation. However, in recessions, there are strong arguments for also using fiscal policy to achieve economic recovery.

  • Fiscal policy involves changing government spending and taxation. It involves a shift in the governments budget position. e.g. Expansionary fiscal policy involves tax cuts, higher government spending and a bigger budget deficit. Government spending is a component of AD.
  • Monetary policy involves influencing the demand and supply of money, primarily through the use of interest rates.
    • Monetary policy can also involve unorthodox policies such as open market operations and quantitative easing.
    • Monetary policy is usually carried out by an independent Central Bank

Overview of monetary and fiscal policy

Reducing Inflation

To reduce inflationary pressures, the government or monetary authorities will try to reduce the growth of AD.

If we use fiscal policy, it will involve higher taxes, lower spending. The advantage of using fiscal policy is that it will help to reduce the budget deficit.

In a country like the UK, with a large budget deficit, it might make sense to use fiscal policy for reducing inflationary pressures because you can reduce inflation and, at the same time, improve the budget deficit.

However, It can be difficult to cut public spending (or increases taxes) for political reasons. This is why most economies have relied on monetary policy for the ‘fine-tuning’ of the economy.

Monetary policy

Raising interest rates is usually quite effective in reducing inflationary pressures. Higher interest rates increase the cost of borrowing and tend to slow down economic activity.

  • However, raising interest rates also affects the exchange rate. Due to hot money flows to take advantage of higher interest rates, the Pound is likely to rise. Therefore, deflationary monetary policy will have a greater effect on exporters.
  • Also raising interest rates has a bigger proportionate effect on homeowners with variable mortgage payments. The high level of mortgage payments means the UK is sensitive to interest rate changes.
  • Monetary policy has a disproportionate effect on the housing market and borrowers.
  • However, higher interest rates can be beneficial for savers who will gain a higher income. SImilarly, the period of very low-interest rates reduces income of those who rely on savings.
  • Therefore monetary policy doesn’t have an even impact throughout the economy; borrowers and savers will be affected differently.

Supply-side effects of fiscal policy

  • Fiscal policy is unlikely to affect the exchange rate.
  • Higher income tax or corporation tax can reduce incentives to work. Business may not like the uncertainty of variable tax rates, and it may lead to lower investment. This is a reason why fiscal policy is rarely (if ever) used for controlling inflation.
  • Cutting government spending could also harm capital investment or lead to lower benefits and increase inequality.

Fiscal vs Monetary policy for dealing with recession

In a recession, monetary policy will involve cutting interest rates to try and stimulate spending and investment. It should also weaken the exchange rate which will help exports.

In the aftermath of the 1992 UK recession, a cut in interest rates (which allowed a devaluation in the over-valued Pound) was very effective in leading to economic growth. The 1992 recession was primarily caused by high-interest rates, so cutting interest rates reduced burden on homeowners and business and allowed the economy to recover.

Limitations of monetary policy

In 2009, interest rates were cut from 5% to 0.5% in the UK (and across the globe). But, interest rate cuts were ineffective in restoring normal growth. In the recession of 2008-09, there was a liquidity trap. Cuts in interest rates were insufficient to encourage spending and investment. This was because:

  • Banks had insufficient credit so were unwilling to lend – despite low-interest rates.
  • Confidence was very low.
  • House prices were falling reducing consumer wealth.
  • With deflation, low-interest rates may be insufficient, because falling prices can still make real interest rates quite high. Therefore, in times of deflation, zero interest rates may not get an economy out of recession.

Unorthodox monetary policy

In addition to cuts in interest rates, another tool of monetary policy is to pursue quantitative easing.

The aim of Quantitative easing is to increase the money supply, reduce bond yields and avoid deflationary pressures.

However, despite the increase in the money supply, the ongoing credit crunch caused banks to save the newly created money, and the effect on increasing growth was limited.

Expansionary fiscal policy

 

Expansionary fiscal policy can directly create jobs and economic activity by injecting demand into the economy. Keynes argued expansionary fiscal policy is necessary in a recession because of the excess private sector saving which arises due to the paradox of thrift. Expansionary fiscal policy enables unused savings to be used and idle resources to be put into work.

In a deep recession and liquidity trap, fiscal policy may be more effective than monetary policy because the government can pay for new investment schemes, creating jobs directly – rather than relying on monetary policy to indirectly encourage business to invest.

The drawback of expansionary fiscal policy is that it increases the budget deficit. Some argue this can lead to higher interest rates as markets require higher interest rates to fund borrowing.

 

However, in many instances, government borrowing can increase in recessions without increasing bond yields. But, it is a balancing act, if borrowing increases too much, markets may fear borrowing is out of control. (see: European fiscal crisis)

Political costs of monetary and fiscal policy

In theory, deflationary policy can reduce inflation. Higher income tax would reduce inflation. However, changing tax rates and government spending is highly political. Neither politicians or voters are likely to accept higher taxes on the basis it is necessary to reduce inflation.

Interest rates set by an independent Central Bank help to take the political calculations out of demand management. In theory, a Central Bank would ignore political considerations and target low inflation. A government may be tempted to encourage an economic boom – just before an election.

Which is best monetary or fiscal policy?

Monetary policy is most widely used for ‘fine-tuning’ the economy. Making minor changes to interest rates is the easiest way to influence the economic cycle. Deflationary fiscal policy is highly politically unpopular.However, in some circumstances, monetary policy has its limitations. In serious recessions, a combination of two policies may be needed.

However, in some circumstances, monetary policy has its limitations. In serious recessions, a combination of the two policies may be needed.

Related

Fiscal And Monetary Policy Essay

The difference between fiscal and monetary policy lies within the different tools wield, and aspects of the economy they influence. Fiscal policy generally deals with different sorts of taxes to manage earnings and spending in the population, and how the government benefits from these interactions. Monetary policy, on the other hand, affects the base value and amount of money in circulation directly, as opposed to simply leveling off amounts from the population to put into federal spending.
There are, primarily, two tools utilizing taxes that are used in fiscal policy to influence the economy. The first of these- Revenue tools- are the taxes collected by the government, both directly and indirectly. We experience direct taxes in the workplace with such things as income tax. As a business owner or CEO, you might have to face corporate taxes and capital gains taxes. Direct taxes can also affect our amount of wealth directly with the aptly named wealth tax, as well as the estate taxes. All of these are progressive taxes- they adjust according to the income of the individual, or the revenue of the company. Because of this, those with an income of up to $7,300 for an individual ($14,000 for a married couple) fall into a smallest tax bracket, and those who make anywhere above $326,451 (individually or combined) fall into the highest tax bracket, and therefore shoulder more of the countries responsibilities. (U.S. IRS). On the flip side, indirect taxes are the taxes that are imposed on goods and services. Sales tax is the most common example of this kind of taxation. This is a regressive tax- flat taxes that will affect every part of the population equally without regards to the individuals income.
The other tool of fiscal policy is the spending tool. This is, in its simplest form, the increase and decrease of government spending. Capital spending- the government investment in economic infrastructure- and transfer payments, which is the redistribution of income from taxpayers to those who need help and financial support- are examples of this tool being implemented.
The tools of monetary policy have to do with the currency in circulation and its value. One of the primary tools implemented by the government is open market purchases and sales- buying and selling different shares to increase or decrease the amount of money in the monetary base. These are usually permanent changes. In case there is a need for a temporary devaluation or increase in monetary amount and value, the government implements repos- the temporary buying or selling of government securities with the intention of the original owner buying back the share. When there is a dearth of money in local banks, a central bank offers them a loan (the discount rate)- another monetary policy tool- which bails them out.
Fiscal and Monetary policy both have their advantages and disadvantages. According to James Tobin, two of the main goals of monetary policy is to ensure the stability of the...

Loading: Checking Spelling

0%

Read more

schwarzenegger and fiscal policy Essay

1803 words - 7 pages California’s Republican governor, Arnold Schwarzenegger, outlined a budget proposal January 9 that constitutes a massive assault on health, education and other social service programs upon which millions of people in the state rely. The $99 billion budget is aimed at eliminating a $14.3 billion gap between expected tax revenues and expenditures. It will include $4.6 billion in cuts, $1 billion in fund shifts from gasoline taxes (by postponing...

Sequestration and Monetary Policy Essay

2566 words - 10 pages President Obama signed the Budget Control Act on the third year of his administrative term. The Budget Control was enacted to address the growing concerns over uncontrolled government spending created by both parties. The Budget control Act was made law to curb government spending by $1.3 trillion over ten year span. Democrats and Republicans have engaged for several decades in unscrupulous bills, pork barrel projects, and bailouts spending...

Monetary Theory and Policy

2230 words - 9 pages Edinburgh Napier University Edinburgh Napier University BA (Hon) Financial Services

Money and Monetary Policy

1587 words - 6 pages Monetary policy and its effects on macroeconomic factors such as GDP, unemployment, inflation, and interest rates.I need help understanding the following MBA macroeconomic problems:A) What are the tools used by the Federal Reserve to control the money supply?The term "monetary policy" refers to the actions undertaken by a central bank, such as the Federal Reserve, to influence the availability and cost of money and credit to help...

Fiscal and Monetary Policies in Japan

4844 words - 19 pages Recommendation to improve financial market – Experiences from Japan 1. The Japanese present financial system – challenges and solutions 1.1. General evaluation of the Japanese current financial system Although suffering the global financial crisis in 2008, the Japanese financial market is steady. The loan market to company gets better after some bad signal in the period 2008-2009. But, the risks of long term financial instruments, say bond,...

EU monetary policy and Turkey

9387 words - 38 pages TABLE OF CONTENTSiLIST OF TABLES 1INTRODUCTION 31. HISTORICAL EVOLUTION OF THE EUROPEAN ECONOMIC AND MONETARY UNION 31.1. A Brief History of European Economic and Monetary Integration 41.1.1. European Payments Union...

Unemployment: Keynesian Ideas and Fiscal Policy

4099 words - 16 pages Fiscal policy, as we know it today, is meant to mitigate unemployment and stabilize the economy through aggregate demand. Despite dismal unemployment numbers, politicians and policy-makers continue to use and be optimistic about the effectiveness of fiscal policy in this regard. Policy as we have seen over the past five years has had dismal effect on the unemployment numbers we are seeing today. It seems we need a policy that will tackle lagging...

Integration in the EU and Monetary Policy

2438 words - 10 pages Integration in the EU and Monetary Policy The creation of the European Union (EU) is a great political and economic feat. For it is the ultimate sign of cooperation between nations that had been in constant rivalry before. Nevertheless, the ideals of such a union cannot stand alone without having a strong foundation and continuos rational decision making by all of the actors involved. If we assume that the European Central Bank’s (ECB)...

Monetary and Economic Policy in Latvia

920 words - 4 pages I. Currency war, also known as “competitive devaluation,” is an international situation in which countries challenge each other in achieving a low exchange rate for their currency. Recently, the most prominent conflict has been that between China and the United States over valuating of the Yuan. This major focus is on China, due to fears that currency manipulation may result in currency wars, and China’s gathering of more than $3 trillion...

Federal Reserve System and Monetary Policy

1363 words - 5 pages Federal Reserve System and Monetary policy Amir Jahangir Federal Reserve System and Monetary policy Introduction United States Federal Reserve system, also known as Federal Reserve or simply “Fed” is the United States central banking system. The Federal Reserve took inception in 1913, after the adoption of the Federal Reserve Act. The United States Congress has mandated three macroeconomic objectives to the Federal Reserve. These are...

The Great Recession Fiscal Policy: Analyzing Problems and Solutions

1879 words - 8 pages As a result of the Great Recession of 2007 to 2009, the United States government implemented various fiscal policies in an effort to stimulate the economy. How the government responded as well as how those responses will affect the U.S. economy into the future are the focus of a proposed research study. In order to ensure an appropriate focus for the proposed research study, problems in existing literature must be evaluated. This paper is...

0 comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *